It is currently 05 Mar 2021, 08:28 |

Customized

for You

Track

Your Progress

Practice

Pays

- Mar
**08**### It's time to save on Magoosh!

09:00 AM PST

-10:00 AM PST

Take 20% off the plan of your choice, now through midnight on 3/8: Code GMAT20Sale - Mar
**08**### Free GRE Prep Hour

08:00 PM EST

-09:00 PM EST

Strategies and techniques for approaching featured GRE topics, 1-hour of live, online instruction. Join March 8th - Mar
**12**### How to Approach GMAT Combinatorics: Key Principles

08:00 PM PST

-09:00 PM PST

Combinatorics is the art of counting. You’ll need to understand this art to do well on the GRE and GMAT.

Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
Updated on: 04 Jul 2019, 23:42

1

Question Stats:

Given \(x\), \(y<0\), what is the value of \(\frac{\sqrt{x^2}}{x} - \sqrt{\frac{-y}{|y|}}\) ?

A. \(1+y\)

B. \(1-y\)

C. \(-1-y\)

D. \(y-1\)

E. \(x-y\)

Hello,

I was looking at the explanation of this question (ID Q02-38, Question2 section 9) and it quite does not make any sense in the very first step (or maybe I am overlooking something). Kindly check (or possibly explain it if possible/and-is-correct).

Thanks

Arsh

A. \(1+y\)

B. \(1-y\)

C. \(-1-y\)

D. \(y-1\)

E. \(x-y\)

Hello,

I was looking at the explanation of this question (ID Q02-38, Question2 section 9) and it quite does not make any sense in the very first step (or maybe I am overlooking something). Kindly check (or possibly explain it if possible/and-is-correct).

Thanks

Arsh

Re: Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
25 Jun 2016, 01:16

1

Expert Reply

Hi,

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

_________________

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

_________________

New to the GRE, and GRE CLUB Forum?

GRE: All you do need to know about the GRE Test | GRE Prep Club for the GRE Exam - The Complete FAQ

Search GRE Specific Questions | Download Vault

Posting Rules: QUANTITATIVE | VERBAL

FREE Resources: GRE Prep Club Official LinkTree Page | Free GRE Materials - Where to get it!! (2020)

Free GRE Prep Club Tests: Got 20 Kudos? You can get Free GRE Prep Club Tests

GRE Prep Club on : Facebook | Instagram

Questions' Banks and Collection:

ETS: ETS Free PowerPrep 1 & 2 All 320 Questions Explanation. | ETS All Official Guides

3rd Party Resource's: All Quant Questions Collection | All Verbal Questions Collection

Books: All GRE Best Books

Scores: The GRE average score at Top 25 Business Schools 2020 Ed. | How to study for GRE retake and score HIGHER - (2020)

How is the GRE Score Calculated -The Definitive Guide (2021)

Tests: GRE Prep Club Tests | FREE GRE Practice Tests [Collection] - New Edition (2021)

Vocab: GRE Prep Club Official Vocabulary Lists for the GRE (2021)

GRE: All you do need to know about the GRE Test | GRE Prep Club for the GRE Exam - The Complete FAQ

Search GRE Specific Questions | Download Vault

Posting Rules: QUANTITATIVE | VERBAL

FREE Resources: GRE Prep Club Official LinkTree Page | Free GRE Materials - Where to get it!! (2020)

Free GRE Prep Club Tests: Got 20 Kudos? You can get Free GRE Prep Club Tests

GRE Prep Club on : Facebook | Instagram

Questions' Banks and Collection:

ETS: ETS Free PowerPrep 1 & 2 All 320 Questions Explanation. | ETS All Official Guides

3rd Party Resource's: All Quant Questions Collection | All Verbal Questions Collection

Books: All GRE Best Books

Scores: The GRE average score at Top 25 Business Schools 2020 Ed. | How to study for GRE retake and score HIGHER - (2020)

How is the GRE Score Calculated -The Definitive Guide (2021)

Tests: GRE Prep Club Tests | FREE GRE Practice Tests [Collection] - New Edition (2021)

Vocab: GRE Prep Club Official Vocabulary Lists for the GRE (2021)

Re: Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
28 Feb 2018, 21:33

Carcass wrote:

Hi,

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

I still don't know why \(\sqrt{\frac{-y}{|y|}}\) =-y NOT -1?

Re: Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
24 May 2018, 11:07

1

Peter wrote:

Carcass wrote:

Hi,

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

well I have to admit that the explanation is not the top-notch but it is not wrong.

Starting from what we do know: X could be positive or negative: we do not know at the moment AND y is negative.

Now look at the first part of the equation \(\sqrt{x^2}\) is equal to |x|. From this we also know that |x| = -x. Which means that on the left hand side X is positive, always. On the right hand side for X to be always positive X must be negative. This are math rules that is better for you to know as cold during the exam.

As such, actually we do have that X/X is = 1 and is negative. So -1

Going to the second square root |y| = -y so -y * - y = y^2 that under square root becomes |y|.

At this point we have -1 - |y| AND we already know that |y| = -y .

-1 - (-y) = -1 +y

Hope is clear this. Waiting, though, math expert for further clarification.

I still don't know why \(\sqrt{\frac{-y}{|y|}}\) =-y NOT -1?

Consider y = (-2), as y<0. hence -y = -(-2) = 2.

|y| = |-2| = 2.

Re: Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
04 Jul 2019, 15:54

1

I was thinking another way. Let me correct if I am horribly wrong! Let x and y both equal -1. from the first, sqrt of (x square)/x we get -1 and also form second part we get -1. So adding, -2. Consider all options!. Option D fits!

Re: Q02-38 Question # 08 Section # 09
[#permalink]
05 Jul 2019, 04:49

Expert Reply

@AlaminMolla is correct. For ALL negative values of x and y, the expression will ALWAYS evaluate to be -2

So, the question is flawed. At the very least, the question should read "Which of the following COULD BE the value of ...", in which case A, D and E COULD equal -2

@arsh are you sure you transcribed the question correctly?

Cheers,

Brent

_________________

So, the question is flawed. At the very least, the question should read "Which of the following COULD BE the value of ...", in which case A, D and E COULD equal -2

@arsh are you sure you transcribed the question correctly?

Cheers,

Brent

_________________

gmatclubot

Moderators:

Multiple-choice Questions — Select One or More Answer Choices |
||

## Hi Guest,Here are updates for you:## ANNOUNCEMENTSEmail Newsletter is Here!
Learn More | Subscribe New Features are Here!
See the full details here ## GRE Prep Club REWARDS |